Do I Need a Home Warranty?
Answer 5 questions about your home's age, systems, and your situation. Get a personalized recommendation in under 2 minutes.
How old is your home?
Home Warranty vs. Homeowners Insurance
These are different products that cover different things:
Homeowners Insurance
- Covers: Damage from disasters, theft, liability
- Examples: Fire, storm damage, break-ins, injuries
- Required: Yes (if you have a mortgage)
- Cost: $1,500-3,000+/year
Home Warranty
- Covers: Systems/appliances that break down
- Examples: AC dies, water heater fails, dishwasher breaks
- Required: No (optional)
- Cost: $300-600/year + service fees
What Home Warranties Typically Cover
Systems
- ✓ HVAC: Heating and air conditioning
- ✓ Plumbing: Pipes, fixtures, water heater
- ✓ Electrical: Wiring, panels, outlets
- ~ Roof leaks: Some plans only
Appliances
- ✓ Kitchen: Refrigerator, oven, dishwasher
- ✓ Laundry: Washer, dryer
- ✓ Water heater: Usually included
- ~ Pool/spa: Add-on coverage
Common Exclusions
Pre-existing conditions, improper maintenance, code violations, cosmetic damage, and structural issues. Coverage limits (caps) may not cover full replacement cost.
Home Warranty Math: Is It Worth It?
Typical Annual Cost
- Annual premium: $400-600
- Service call fee (per visit): $75-125
- Total if 2 service calls: $550-850/year
Common Repair Costs (Without Warranty)
- HVAC repair: $150-500 | Replacement: $5,000-10,000
- Water heater replacement: $800-2,000
- Refrigerator repair: $200-400
- Plumbing repair: $150-500
Break-even analysis: You'd need 2-3 repairs per year worth $400+ to break even. One major repair (like HVAC) could easily pay for years of premiums.
Major Home Warranty Companies
| Company | Annual Cost | Service Fee | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Home Shield | $300-600 | $75-125 | Largest provider, wide coverage |
| Choice Home Warranty | $350-550 | $85 | Good value, fast claims |
| First American | $350-500 | $75-100 | Good customer service |
| Select Home Warranty | $300-450 | $60-75 | Budget option, lower limits |
Tip: Read reviews carefully. Customer experiences vary widely. Check BBB ratings and complaint histories before choosing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between home warranty and homeowners insurance?
Homeowners insurance covers damage from disasters (fire, theft, storms). Home warranty covers repair/replacement of systems and appliances that break down from normal wear and tear. They're complementary, not overlapping - you may want both.
What does a home warranty actually cover?
Typically: HVAC, plumbing, electrical systems, water heater, and major appliances (washer, dryer, refrigerator, oven). Coverage varies by plan - basic plans cover less, comprehensive plans cover more. Always read the contract carefully for exclusions and limits.
Are home warranties worth it financially?
It depends on your situation. Plans cost $300-600/year plus $75-125 per service call. You'd need 2-3 repairs per year to break even. They're worth it if you have older systems, tight budget, or can't handle surprise repairs. Not worth it for new homes or handy DIYers with emergency funds.
What are common home warranty exclusions?
Pre-existing conditions (problems that existed before coverage), improper maintenance, code violations, cosmetic issues, and items not specifically listed. Coverage limits (caps) are common - your HVAC might only be covered up to $1,500 when replacement costs $5,000+.
Should I get a home warranty when buying a house?
Often yes, especially for older homes or if you're unfamiliar with the property's history. Sellers sometimes include them as a sales incentive. Use the first year to learn about your home's systems, build contractor relationships, then decide if renewal makes sense.
How do I file a home warranty claim?
Call the warranty company's service line (usually available 24/7). They'll assign a contractor from their network. You pay the service fee ($75-125) when the contractor arrives. Repairs are typically completed within a few days to a week, depending on parts availability.